The Market Is Always Right…Until It's Not

08/19/2015 6:00 am EST

Focus: STRATEGIES

Jim Farrish

Founder and CIO, Jim's Notes

Though it may seem easy for traders to make a case for selling stocks and being defensive versus the current market environment, Jim Farrish, on Jim’s Notes, offers a different possible course of action since stock prices have continued to find a way to reinvent themselves time and time again.

One of the biggest mistakes investors and traders make relative to markets is believing we are right and the market is wrong. If you find yourself making comments such as, ‘it can’t being doing that because_________,” you may be trying to tell the market what to do. “Based on ________ this stock should be going higher,” you may be trying to tell the market what to do. It is important to have a belief about the markets, it is important to have a belief in direction that is based on a successful strategy, but it is equally important to let the market validate your belief over time. If it fails to validate your belief, you don’t put your money in harms way. If it fails to validate your beliefs…your beliefs may not be valid…now. The single biggest losses I experienced as an investor were from not listening or accepting what the market was saying. Being stubborn and believing I was right and the market was wrong. The market, in essence, was saying to me it didn’t care what I believed. And in the end, I may have been right eventually, but the likelihood I would stick with the investment through all the downside pain were not that good, in fact, they were downright slim…thus the biggest losses were when the pain of being wrong was exceeded only by the pain of losing money. You may be right eventually, but how much pain can you tolerate as the market trades opposite of your belief? Let’s put this in perspective of today’s current market environment…

Despite the sideways trading over the last five months the market keeps rolling, taking each story, data point, speculation, or fear and turning it into lemonade. It seems that no matter what the buyers continue to step in and prop the markets up, all things considered, the markets have held up well. Thus, my point is that no matter what we think, the data says the market has held serve and remains in an uptrend.

NEXT PAGE: Some Key Issues and the Best Course of Action

|pagebreak|

Some of the key issues facing the market currently:

  1. China is in transition. The slowing economic picture continues to weigh on the outlook for stocks. They have devalued the yuan to compete globally on price. The blatant interference run by government to circumvent selling of stocks, lending, valuation of currency, foreign involvement of business, etc. are all weighing on the valuation of the stocks and the US markets relative to currency and economic growth. Speculation is running rampant about what it all means. FXI is holding support near the lows ($39.70) and only time will determine how it unfolds. The bias is on the downside, but it will all have to validate if the short trades are worth the risk of the investment going forward.
  2. Earnings growth is nonexistent. Corporate profits have slowed again. Stock buybacks, dividends, and M&A activity have been the driving factors. The lack of earnings growth is a big issue looking forward, but the markets have been willing to overlook the concerns. Until it is an investable downside catalyst…don’t fight it.
  3. The dollar remains strong. This hurts the US exports. The added pressure of the yuan activity by China is only adding to the issue with the stronger dollar.
  4. Oil, metals, soft agriculture, and gold have all suffered downturns. The demand has fallen as a result of the global economic weakness. Throw in the strong dollar hitting the price of commodities and you get plenty of questions about when they will bottom. Believing this is the bottom is fools gold. Let it validate.
  5. Stock valuations (P/E) aren’t exactly cheap. With the lack of growth in earnings (above), this isn’t stirring any confidence in investors.
  6. Federal Reserve wants to hike interest rates in the face of slower growth? Yes, it is determined on the process. It may well have missed the window of opportunity to raise rates without economic impact and that is causing some angst among investors. The Fed remains a big black cloud over the markets. Betting against the Fed is always a losing proposition.

It is easy to make a case for selling stocks and being defensive versus the current market environment. But, stock prices have continued to find a way to reinvent themselves time and time again. Going against the market because we believe it is wrong is a bet, generally, better not taken. Sitting on the sidelines avoids the brain damage inflicted by being wrong.

The best course of action is to follow your strategy in light of the current trends in place. Define your time horizon for your trading. Define your risk relative to entry, stop, and targets. Follow your discipline and turn off the talking heads on the financial channels. Focus on your habits and follow the strategy as it is laid out. If your strategy(s) are not working, stop trading, investing, or beating your head against the market. Take what it gives, but if it keeps taking your money stop trading. Sit on the sidelines until which time the opportunities are in favor with your strategy and style of investing. The market is always right...right now. Time will tell what works, but don’t fight the market…it tends to win...and sometimes by a knockout.

By Jim Farrish, Founder & CIO, Jim’s Notes

Related Articles on STRATEGIES