The Biggest Winners from the Crisis
09/16/2010 3:51 pm EST
The final fall of the House of Lehman occurred two years ago this week, marking the last, desperate phase of the financial crisis that almost undid the world economy.
Now, as the dust clears, some winners and losers have emerged. And we may eventually look back on the crisis as an inflection point when some countries leaped ahead, while others fell behind.
So far the emerging markets of Asia and Latin America have been the big winners, along with some of the Nordic countries. Their economies are booming while their stock markets have surged.
“Emerging markets have definitely been the stars of the show,” says Alexander Young, international equity strategist for Standard & Poor’s Equity Research Services.
The winners were countries that improved their competitiveness without getting too deeply into debt.
The big losers, of course, were the countries along the European periphery and others that got stretched too thin, living off the false hopes of the credit boom of the 2000s.
“The controlling idea here is debt,” says Nicholas Vardy, who writes the Global Stock Investor and Global Guru investment newsletters from London. “In the very big picture, a lot of the growth from western Europe and US has been from debt. Now the shoe is on the other foot.”
Indeed it is. Although some developed markets have emerged unscathed from the crisis, the emerging markets—especially those just below the BRICs (Brazil, Russia, India, and China)—have been among the biggest winners.
Here are my picks of the biggest winners since the fall of Lehman Brothers, based on stock market performance, gross domestic product growth, and intangible factors, such as relative change in economic and political status. (My choice of losers will follow next week.)
|1.||Singapore. Singapore, the tiny city-state south of China with a population of less than four million, will see gross domestic product growth of an astonishing 15% this year, economists predict. A surge of exports has set the pace, while tourism—spurred by the opening of the city-state’s first two Macau/Las Vegas-style casinos this year—has also picked up. As Vardy points out:
“Singapore has been ranked [number one] in global innovation and competitiveness. It’s ranked first for having the most open economy for international trade and investment.”
Its stock market is the strongest among all developed markets, up 21.57% over the last year, and it has risen at a 12.7% annual clip since the fall of Lehman.
|2.||Malaysia and Indonesia. Malaysia, which expelled Singapore in 1965, has also prospered. Its population of 27 million is about half Malay Muslims, with large communities of people of Chinese and Indian descent. Having installed capital controls during the Asian crisis of the 1990s (and blaming speculators like George Soros for a run on the ringgit), the country refused aid from the International Monetary Fund. Eventually GDP growth returned, and economists predict it will hit 6.5% this year. Malaysian stocks have risen 36% over the last 12 months and have clocked a nearly 25% annual return over the last two years.
Nearby Indonesia has been the star of emerging Asia. The vast archipelago of more than 17,000 islands has the world’s fourth largest population (248 million) and the largest Muslim population. A “can-do” government, led by a former general, President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono, has crusaded against corruption and begun to upgrade the country’s backward infrastructure.
Since the Asian crisis, it has cut government debt to around 30% of GDP. (Ours is projected to hit 100% next year.) Indonesia’s GDP could grow by 6% in 2010. Its stock market has soared 39% over the past year, and has surged 35.527% annually since Lehman’s collapse.
Next: Latin America Emerges
Emerging Latin America. Once the land of Pablo Escobar and the “cocaine cowboys,” Colombia finally won a decades-long guerilla war and the drug trade moved north to Mexico. Rich in natural resources and with an industrious population of 44 million, Colombia’s economy has taken off—GDP could rise by 5% for 2010. Its stock market has been simply the world’s best—up 61% in the past 12 months and 36% annually over the last two years. It also has been the top performer over the last ten years, rising 38.6% annually. No lost decade there!
Copper-rich Peru and conservative Chile, which has one of the freest economies in Latin America, also posted some amazing stock market returns over the last two years. Both Peru and Chile have little government debt. Their markets have outpaced Brazil’s, which also must be viewed as one of the big winners.
|4.||The Nordic countries have been among the pacesetters in the developed world. In Sweden, prime minister Fredrik Reinfeldt, who ended the decades-long rule of the Social Democrats in 2006, has cut taxes and reduced Sweden’s notorious long-term sick leave (though Sweden’s welfare state remains intact). Sweden also tightened banking regulation after its own banking crisis in the early 1990s, and thus avoided this one. Its market, up 21.57% over the past year, has advanced 11.9% annually since Lehman’s fall.
Denmark, too, has been among the strongest markets in the developed world, while Norway, whose market is tied to the price of crude, has one of the strongest currencies on the planet, the krone, and a huge trade surplus.
|5.||Canada and Australia. The two former British colonies—both with huge land masses and small populations—have benefited from their competitiveness, fiscal prudence, and especially their wealth of natural resources, which have fueled China’s boom.
Iron ore, coal, oil shale, and grains are only a few of the natural gifts with which these countries are blessed. Australia is called “the lucky country,” and that moniker could be applied to Canada, too.
But it wasn’t just luck. Australia’s Big Four and Canada’s Big Five banks are among the world’s soundest, having avoided the reckless risk-taking that brought down so many proud names—like Lehman. Both central banks have actually raised interest rates.
Their rich natural resources and stable finances have kept their currencies strong as well: The Aussie dollar has been red-hot lately, hitting a two-year high, while the loonie is again close to parity with the greenback.
The Aussie market, the world’s best performer over the last century, has averaged 6.8% returns over the last two years, and is up 11% over the past 12 months, as is Canada’s. Their markets have been strong over the past five years as well.
Honorable mention: Although its stock market has underperformed those of its rapidly growing Asian peers, China has been a powerful economic force, routinely posting double-digit-percentage GDP growth. As it keeps surpassing one country after the other in the global economic rankings (it’s now the world’s second largest economy).
China continues to gain in strength and influence. Future historians may well view this decade as the one in which it emerged as a genuine superpower.
Will China—and India—turn out to be the biggest winners from the financial crisis that exploded two years ago with the fall of Lehman Brothers? We may not know for some time, but our children surely will.
ETFs of markets mentioned in this column:
iShares MSCI Singapore Index (NYSEArca: EWS)
iShares MSCI Malaysia Index (NYSEArca: EWM)
Market Vectors Indonesia (NYSEArca: IDX)
GlobalX/InterBolsa FTSE Colombia 20 (NYSEArca: GXG)
iShares MSCI Chile Investable Market Index (NYSEArca: ECH)
Global X FTSE Nordic 30 ETF (NYSEArca: GXF)
iShares MSCI Australia Index (NYSEArca: EWA)
iShares MSCI Canada Index (NYSEArca: EWC)