The Truth Behind the Data

08/05/2008 12:00 am EST


Joe Battipaglia

Market Strategist-Private Client Group, Stifel Nicolaus

Joe Battipaglia, market strategist—private client group of Stifel, Nicholas, explains why economic data like GDP growth give a misleading picture of the economy.

[Last week’s] report of second quarter GDP growth included a negative number for the fourth quarter of 2007, which is coincident with our March 10th Commentary where we posited that a recession began in the fourth quarter of last year.

Our concern has been that the consumer in the United States has become weakened because of falling employment, tighter credit, and a large debt overhang from the housing bubble. The reason we are focused on what is going on inside the US is because much of the demand for goods and services produced around the world emanates from the US consumer.  It is hard to envision a robust global economy when the engine of the largest economy in the world is not functioning properly.

According to Bernard Baumohl, executive director of the Economic Outlook Group, LLC, and author of The Secrets of Economic Indicators, the data for "gross domestic purchases and for the GDP move in tandem—except for periods when the cost of imports surges. That can happen when oil prices shoot up or if the dollar plummets in value, which automatically makes imports more expensive. In such instances, gross domestic purchases turns out to be a better gauge." 

The headline statistics currently show modest economic growth of 1.9% with low inflation of just 1.1%.  Even a casual observer of the economy might wonder what these figures are missing.  Where is the collapse in automobile demand?  Where is the credit crunch?  Where are the lost jobs? It just doesn't square with what we commonly know about the economy's troubles lately.

Perhaps if we sharpen our focus on core demand in the US by removing exports and inventory changes, we get a picture that many would agree more accurately reflects the current conditions.  Here we see that core consumer demand at home is a negative -0.5% while prices are up 4.3%.  That reality, in our view, more closely reflects the experience of the "man on the street" and not the "headline" figures on the economy. 

Perhaps more important is the fact that investors who have looked at the economy's trends in this light have been better able to spot the deterioration that has weighted on financial markets for most of the past year.

So, while the Bureau of Economic Analysis's report on production shows growth, the crux of our issue has not been on the production side. It has been on what happens to consumer demand both currently and [in the future]. 

A falling dollar will generally curtail growth in imports and strengthen exports. A falling dollar and shifting trade balance is not necessarily a sign of strength, but can be a result of weakness. On the bright side, we are encouraged by the apparent drawdown in inventories, which is a potential harbinger of improved production trends looking out into future quarters.

Related Articles on MARKETS