Selectively Greedy in Midstream Energy

09/25/2015 7:00 am EST


Josh Peters

Editor, Morningstar DividendInvestor

The meltdown in the midstream energy sector may be an overreaction, but it also reflects legitimate headwinds for businesses that are not always the toll roads that industry promoters claim they are, explains Josh Peters, editor of Morningstar DividendInvestor.

It’s not too early to be selectively greedy. Our picks, chosen for wide moats, resilient distribution growth, and—most important—financial strength, are Magellan Midstream (MMP), Spectra Energy Partners (SEP), and our recent buy Enterprise Products (EPD).

But if it’s not too early to be selectively greedy, it’s certainly not too late to be generally fearful. If energy prices don’t rebound soon, more halts to distribution growth as well as outright cuts are probably coming.

These actions could cast the whole group—even top-shelf names like ours—in a poor light for a while.

Oil that is only worth drilling for at $100 a barrel will stay in the ground at $45. Less drilling activity means lower production, lower production means less midstream infrastructure is needed, and with less investment we can expect distribution growth rates to fall across the industry.

Recently, we’ve reflected this dynamic with reduced fair value estimates. Magellan’s fair value fell $8 to $80 a unit, Enterprise Products’ fair value dropped $2 to $36, and our appraisal of SEP fell $8 to $55.

The good news is threefold:

1) All three provide excess coverage for distributions that is healthy relative to the volatility of their cash flows. SEP has extremely stable cash flow, so its coverage of 1.1 times still offers an appropriate buffer.

Magellan has a bit more variability, but if anything, its coverage of 1.4 times is far higher than it needs to be.

Of our three holdings, Enterprise is the most sensitive to energy prices, but its coverage ratio of 1.4 times does more than provide an adequate margin of safety.

2) All three of these partnerships are likely to continue increasing their quarterly distributions.

Thanks to new fee-based assets and growth for its favorably regulated refined products system, Magellan remains on track to raise its distribution 15% this year and 10% (or better) for 2016.

SEP has a huge backlog of heavily contracted projects in place to drive continued growth of $0.0125 a unit each quarter (about 8% annually) through 2017.

At Enterprise, new projects being placed in service plus the shield of substantial excess coverage make the current trend of $0.005 a unit quarterly hikes likely to continue through the current downturn.

As an investor, I think it’s best to approach this decline from a position of fear, while taking advantage of attractive valuations by gradually raising our stakes in high-quality firms.

We don’t need a pound-the-table moment; continued consistency from our selected MLPs will do fine.

Subscribe to Morningstar Dividend Investor…

More from

Stonemor: High Yield from Grim Reaper

Crude Realities: Capitulation?

High Yield from InfraCap MLP

  By clicking submit, you agree to our privacy policy & terms of service.

Related Articles on ENERGY

Keyword Image
Chevron: "A Leap of Faith"
12/05/2018 5:00 am EST

It requires a leap of faith to buy an energy stock when oil prices are falling. But Chevron (CVX) se...

Keyword Image
Carl Icahn Eyes CVR Energy
11/28/2018 5:00 am EST

I like to invest alongside CEOs that have a hot hand and, of late, one of them is Carl Icahn, as he ...