Pullback Creates Value for Franco-Nevada
04/11/2018 5:00 am EST
First, declines in the broad stock market affect Franco more than most gold companies, given that it is widely held by generalist funds, whose fund flows are more sensitive to the general market.
Second, Franco-Nevada disclosed in its recent MD&A report that the Canadian Revenue Agency (CRA) was conducting an audit of the company’s 2012, 2013, and 2014 tax returns.
This follows the very public dispute between CRA and Wheaton Precious Metals (WPM) over the way it books revenue from its offshore subsidiary.
Booking revenues from offshore streams through offshore entities is very common, and both companies have said that they believe they are fully complying with the rules and regulations.
Were Franco’s structures to be disallowed, the back taxes owed would be relatively minor: approximately 9% of total revenues for 2012 and 2013 and 19% for 2014 (or a total 5% of total Net Asset Value), meaningfully less than for Wheaton Precious Metals.
Going forward, however, the impact would be more meaningful, since Franco has invested in major streaming deals in recent years, mostly through the offshore units.
Franco remains a top company, with solid balance sheet, strong cash flow, and a deep pipeline. Notwithstanding the potential result of the tax examination, Franco is a strong buy here after the recent price decline.