Avoiding Those Costly Impulsive Trades
06/11/2015 6:00 am EST
Using reference points from monthly charts, traders can identify more effective stop levels and stay with major trend moves much longer, thus increasing their profits, according to technician Tom Aspray.
In over 30 years of looking at charts of stock and commodity market indices, I have often been struck in hindsight by the lengthy trending periods that are evident in some markets. Over the years, I have sought to improve not only in identifying the market turns, but also improving my ability to catch larger portions of these trends.
From my own experience and the observations of others, there seems to be a familiar pattern. An investor or trader will often catch the start of a good market trend and may capture most of the first major market swing. However, once the market has a significant correction, they will often lose interest or move on to another market. Therefore, they will often miss the next major part of the trend, which is often even larger than the first.
I have had the most success in identifying the major market trends by using monthly charts and technical studies. The monthly on-balance volume (OBV) for gold completed its bottom in 2002 and stayed positive for ten years. The writing of my regular monthly column on the Dow stocks has further reinforced the importance of not only the monthly patterns, but also the monthly price ranges.
In my opinion, a poor entry price causes the most damage to an account and that is why I strongly emphasize calculating the risk on every position. The combination of tight monthly ranges, monthly chart formations, and monthly OBV has helped me to identify some good opportunities.
MSFT traded in about a $4 range for the five months of 2011 with the low of $23.79 coming in August of that year. The stock closed at $25.96 on December 31, 2011, then gapped higher to start off 2012, opening at $26.55. It closed January 2012 at $29.53 and made a high in April 2012 of $32.95.
The Coca Cola Co. (KO) also was locked in a tight range from December 2011 through February 2012. The December 2011 low was $65.88 and the high in January 2012 was $70.71. The range in February was even tighter ($67.42 to $69.98), but KO then surged in March to close near the highs at $74.10. For both MSFT and KO, the initial stops were placed beneath monthly lows.
So, how can monthly charts be used by both investors and traders? One approach I have been examining is to use the prior month’s high or low as a stop level. Long positions would be favored based on bullish signals from the OBV and stops would be based on the prior month’s low.
NEXT: One of the Stock Market’s Best Trending Periods
As I have said in the past, I do not recommend using a stop at the actual high or low, but instead suggest using a level that is half of one percentage point, or 0.005%, above or below the monthly range. In these examples, the actual low will be put in parentheses.
One of the stock market’s best trending periods in the past 18 years was from late 1994 through the middle of 1998. This chart of the Spyder Trust (SPY) covers this period.
In December 1994, SPY formed a doji (a sign of indecision), and in January 1996, SPY closed above the prior month’s high and the OBV turned positive. The ETF closed the month at $46.84 and longs would have been established on the February opening at $46.91.
For the month of February, the stop would have been at $45.23 ($45.45 was January’s low). SPY closed higher in February, and so for March, the stop was at $46.53 ($46.76 was February’s low). For the purposes of this discussion, I will consider the position stopped out, as the low during the first week of March, 1995 was $46.53.
The monthly OBV was positive, so new longs would be established on a move above the prior month’s high. SPY opened April 1995 at $49.83, so new longs should have been established at that time.
SPY did not make a new monthly low until January 1997, when the December 1996 stop at $59.95 ($60.26 was December’s high) was broken when January’s low was $59.33. This would have amounted to a 20% gain in eight months.
In February 1997, the January high of $63.36 was exceeded, and for the next five months, SPY edged higher. In July 1997 (point 3), the June stop at $65.48 was hit (June’s low was $65.81) when SPY had a low that month of $60.06.
Just two months later, in September 1997, new longs would have been established when SPY moved above the prior month’s high of $67. This position would not have been stopped out until March 1997 (point 3) when the stop at $76.73 ($77.12 was March high) would have been hit once SPY dropped as low as $75.25.
The monthly OBV was still confirming the price action and was above its weighted moving average (WMA), so when SPY moved above the April 1997 high at $80.69 in May, it was a signal to go long. The stop should have been at $72.94 (April low was $73.31). This would have been a risk of 9.2%.
This long position was held until October 1997 (point 4) when the September stop at $89.80 ($90.25) was triggered. On this correction, the OBV dropped sharply but did hold above the rising weighted moving average.
Two months later, in December 1997, the November high at $99 was exceeded. This signal was reversed in January 1998 (point 5) when the December stop at $91.90 ($92.37) was hit.
SPY opened February 1998 at $99.91, which was above the January high. On these new longs, a stop at $90.46 (0.005% under the January lows at $90.91) would have been used.
This position would have been held until August 1998, point 6, when SPY dropped below the July stop at $110.75 ($111.31). A new buy signal was generated in October 1998 at $107 (not shown) and was not stopped out until May 1999. SPY closed the year at $123.31.
Over the three-year period, these eight trades would have netted almost 70% of the potential gain if one simply bought on the opening in 1995 and sold on the last day of 1998. There were eight trades and 75% of them were profitable.
Let’s now examine how this translates to other markets. Most think of the forex market as being particularly volatile and a high percentage of forex traders fail. One common complaint is that many have difficulty placing their stops.
NEXT: Using Monthly Highs and Lows to Trade Forex|pagebreak|
Therefore, I wanted to look at how using the monthly highs and lows as stops would work in the Euro FX Futures. For over 30 years, I have found that the OBV is a very useful tool for forecasting the moves in the currency markets. In this example, I will be using the weekly OBV and its weighted moving average as a trigger.
The chart covers the period from March 2009 through March 2012. The last seven months of 2012 were particularly interesting, as the euro also came under pressure that summer when concerns grew over Greece’s debt burden then too.
The OBV dropped below its weighted moving average in June 2010 and the lower lows in July started a new downtrend in the OBV. At the end of July of that year, volume rallied back to its flat weighted moving average, which is a classic topping formation. The first week of August 2011, the uptrend in the OBV, line c, was broken, confirming a new sell signal.
The euro opened the following week at 1.4256 and a stop at 1.4620 (0.005% above the July high of 1.4547) would have been used on short positions. The euro came quite close to this stop when it made a high on August 29, 2011 at 1.4553.
The weekly OBV stayed below its weighted moving average for the next seven months, as it formed a series of lower highs and lower lows until the week ending March 23, 2012 when the weekly OBV moved back above.
FX traders should also note that the weekly OBV did a good job of catching the euro’s decline from November 2009 through May 2010. Even if trading the spot FX market, keeping an eye on the volume in the currency futures is a good idea.
On the daily chart of the euro futures, the break of weekly OBV support and the confirmation of a new downtrend is identified by point 1. Those who use the OBV will not be surprised to see that the euro continued to edge higher for two weeks before dropping sharply. The weekly OBV can often be a very good leading indicator.
For the next five months, the euro stayed well below the stop (red line), as calculated from the prior month’s high, which is indicated on the chart.
Then, on February 9, 2012, the euro had a high 1.3325 (point 2) and just above the stop at 1.3301, which was derived from January’s monthly high of 1.3237. After a sharp setback, the euro continued to rally, eventually reaching a high of 1.3487.
As noted in this April 4, 2012 column, the technical action suggested that the rebound in the euro was over and that the rally from the January lows was just a pause in the downtrend. The flag formation is consistent with a continuation pattern.
Using the monthly stop method, those who were short then could have used a stop at 1.3457, which is calculated from the March 2012 high of 1.3391.
For some FX traders, a stop half of one percentage point above the monthly high might be too wide, and in this example, a stop that was one 1/4 of a % above the month’s high would not have altered the results. For April, 2012 that would have meant a stop of 1.3424, which was 33 pips lower.
NEXT: An Alternative Way to Apply This Concept
An alternative way to apply the same concept would be to use the monthly pivot levels instead of the monthly high or low. If the OBV or other technical measures were positive, then a stop would be used half of 1% below the monthly pivot. Conversely, on short positions, a stop one half of 1% above the monthly pivot would be used.
This weekly chart of Apple, Inc. (AAPL) from 2012 shows the powerful rally from that year, which clearly qualified as a trending move. The week before Christmas 2011, AAPL closed at $403.33, which was well above the prior five-week highs. The first week in January 2012, AAPL closed at $422.40, which was above both the November and December 2011 highs.
The monthly pivot for January was $397.26, and half of one percent below that would have been $395.27.
Over the first four months of 2012, AAPL had only come close to its monthly pivot once (in early March) when it made a low of $516.22. The monthly pivot was at $514.68, so the adjusted stop based on this pivot would have been $512.10. For April 2012, the pivot was at $579.07, so an adjusted stop at $576.17 could have been used. Apple had not made a lower monthly low since October 2011.
For a good example of how this might be applied in a downtrending market, we can take a look at NetFlix, Inc. (NFLX), which had an historic decline in the second half of 2011.
By the end of July 2011, the monthly pivot for July at $260.17 had been broken. On short positions, the August pivot stood at $274.08, so a stop at $275.48 (half of one percentage point above) could have been used for a stop.
In September, the monthly pivot was $235.95 (adjusted to $237.12), which was just barely exceeded on the first day of September when the high was $238.50. Of course, NFLX continued to plunge, hitting a low in early December 2011 of $62.37.
NFLX stayed below its monthly pivot after September 1 and up to December 12, when the monthly pivot stop at $73.95 ($73.58) was exceeded.
If, instead, using monthly highs for NFLX, the short position would not have been stopped out until January 4, 2012, when the stop based on December’s monthly high of $77.97 was exceeded.
So how can you apply this monthly analysis to your trading or investing? I hope most of you keep a written record, or journal, of your market analysis. I think it will definitely pay off in the long run.
Each month, this record should include the month’s high and low for each of the markets you are following. Every month, compare the new numbers with the prior month’s ranges. This should be done not only for markets in which you are already invested, but also for those you are watching.
Related Articles on STRATEGIES
Profit from a market by capturing a trend. Money management is key. The battle is often from within,...
Has Mr. Market (S&P 500/Equities) priced into too much positivity, while inflation remains at ba...
Berkshire Hathaway (BRK.B) is well known as the huge operating and investment company that was built...