Diwali Gold Loses Shine as Prices Rise
11/14/2012 11:30 am EST
Festival season is a peak period for gold sales in India. However, demand has recently been slack as the extra expense leaves customers hesitant, write Rebecca Bundhun and Gregor Stuart Hunter of The National.
Arendra Thakur, a commander in the Indian navy, splashed out 250,000 rupees ($4,560) on gold jewelry for his wife and daughter at a jeweler in Mumbai over the weekend.
Prices were higher than last year but he could not forgo the annual tradition of buying gold for the Diwali festival, he says. "Every year I purchase some items for Diwali. Everybody buys gifts for the celebration."
The gold price in dollars is up on the festive season last year, and weakness in the Indian rupee against the dollar pushes that rate even higher. As a result, gold prices in India in rupees are much higher: about 32,000 rupees per ten grams, compared with about 27,000 rupees during the festival last year.
Even though jewelry shops across India have been busy as usual with customers for Diwali, shop owners say the expense is dampening demand. "Prices are high, so customers are a little hesitant to buy gold right now," says Dheeraj Jain, the co-owner of Surana Gold, a jewelry shop in Mumbai.
Most purchases were normally made during the festival and even just after, so it is too early to predict whether it will turn out to be better or worse than last year, he adds. "Let's hope for the best," says Jain.
Rajendra Gurjar, the owner of the Gurjar Gold and Diamond jewelers, says sales are flat so far on last year. "Gold prices are increasing," he says. "But that means that customers can gain on the gold they buy."
Diwali is keenly watched by international gold traders because of the effect it has on physical gold sales. India is the world's biggest consumer of gold jewelry, and Diwali—which is followed by the wedding season—is a peak period for sales.
Compared with past years, demand ahead of the festival has been slack, Gerhard Schubert, the head of precious metals at Emirates NBD, wrote in a research note. "The strength of physical buying out of India has still been underwhelming, but there have been pockets of very good demand from the subcontinent," he wrote.
"Diwali is upon us, and it is too early to state the level of additional sales visible for the festival compared with normal market expectations...Nevertheless, last week was the week for the gold bugs, as the market demonstrated some strength in depth and vigor," he continued.
Gold investment and jewelry demand in India fell to 181.3 tonnes in the second quarter of this year, down from 294.5 tonnes during the same period last year, according to data from the World Gold Council, citing the fluctuations in the rupee and inflationary pressure in India.
Investment demand in India, at 56.5 tonnes, was less than half the level it was in the second quarter of last year, while demand for gold jewelry in India declined 30% to 124.8 tonnes during the quarter, the data showed.
Gold prices globally have picked up on the back of actions by the United States Federal Reserve to steady the world's largest economy. Two rounds of quantitative easing, followed by the Fed's Operation Twist last year and a third open-ended round of bond-buying, have all contributed to inflationary fears—prompting a rush towards havens such as gold.
Since 2007, the price of bullion has increased by more than 150%, to about $1,730 per ounce.
The Fed has been joined by pledges of additional bond-buying from the European Central Bank, the Bank of England, and the Bank of Japan, which have contributed to boosting the price of the yellow metal in recent months.
However, economists are skeptical of how much longer gold's allure can last for investors.
"You're only entitled to one 30-fold bull market once in a generation," says Richard Hoey, the chief economist at BNY Mellon. "The fundamental today is low, short-term interest rates relative to inflation. I believe real short-term interest rates adjusted for inflation in important financial centers is a crucial determinant in the interest in gold. We're probably at the lowest ever seen in world history."
Whether the historic highs will be sustained throughout another five years of Diwali festivals is unlikely, but Hoey says the question is, when will gold retreat?
"There's a day of reckoning of higher interest rates to come in the coming years," he adds. "But I'm not convinced it's going to start soon."