How the Strong ADP Jobs Report Steepens the Treasury Yield Curve

08/06/2018 10:52 am EST


Don Kaufman

Co-Founder, TheoTrade

There were a few solid economic reports which pushed the 10-year Treasury yield to 3% besides the uptick in the Japanese 10-year yield. One of those reports was the ADP private sector payrolls report, writes Don Kaufman.

The ADP Research Institute report showed 219,000 jobs were created in July which beat the consensus for 173,000 jobs. The high end of the expectations range was 220,000. June’s report was revised up from 177,000 to 181,000. This was the first month which added more than 200,000 jobs since February which is the month many consider to be the peak in manufacturing growth.

Since the ADP report was below the BLS report in the past two months, some are thinking this means the BLS report will show over 219,000 jobs created. That wouldn’t shock me because the jobless claims were very low in the week the BLS survey was conducted in July. While we’re on the topic of jobless claims, the claims reported on Thursday were 218,000 which met the consensus and were up 1,000 from the prior week. The 4-week moving average fell from 218,000 to 214,500. The consensus for the BLS report, which will be released Friday, is for 190,000 jobs created and for the participation rate to fall from 62.9% to 62.8%. Private payrolls are only expected to be up 184,000.

Looking deeper into the report, small businesses added 52,000 jobs, mid-sized businesses added 119,000 jobs, and large businesses added 48,000 jobs. Goods producing businesses added 42,000 jobs. Natural resources and mining added only 3,000 jobs which makes sense because July was a rough month for oil prices. Oil had its worst month in 2 years as it fell about 7%.

Manufacturing added 23,000 jobs which makes sense because of the strong regional Fed reports and the decent ISM Manufacturing report which I will review in a future article. Construction added 17,000 jobs. This sector will be pressured if the weakness in the housing sector continues. Weakness is spurring from rising rates which hurt affordability.

The service providing sector added 177,000 jobs which is the size of the entire economy’s job creation in June according to ADP. The increase was driven by education and health, professional and business, and leisure and hospitality which added 48,000, 47,000, and 37,000 jobs respectively.

Weakness in auto sales

July auto sales were weak which is a bad signal for Q3 GDP growth and is in line with the weakness in the ECRI leading index report. As you can see in the chart below, the seasonally adjusted annual run rate of light vehicle sales was only 16.8 million which missed estimates for 17.1 million. June’s report was revised down from 17.5 million to 17.2 million. July’s sales were the lowest rate since August of last year which was weakened by a hurricane.

chart 1

The good news is it doesn’t look like the climate is conducive for hurricanes this year. This means there won’t be weakness followed by a huge bump in replacement sales. We didn’t need a hurricane for weakness in July. Until I see other weak economic reports besides the ECRI leading index, I will expect light vehicle sales to remain at the current plateau.

Seasonally adjusted domestic vehicle sales were 13.1 million which beat the consensus for 12.9 million but fell from the revised June report which had sales of 13.4 million. Import sales fell from 3.8 million in June to 3.7 million in July.

The weakness in auto sales will hurt the July retail sales report because vehicle sales are 20% of retail sales. This means retail sales will be flat instead of the strong growth seen in Q2. The July retail sales report will be released on August 15. Retail sales were up 0.5% month over month in June; excluding autos, the increase was 0.4%.

Sequentially weak construction spending report

Construction spending was weak sequentially in July. It was down 1.1% month over month which missed the consensus for 0.3% growth widely. The lowest estimate was for -0.3% meaning the weakness was way below estimates. The revision upwards in the June report was partially responsible for this decline as growth was pushed up from 0.4% to 1.3%.

As you can see from the chart below, June year over year spending growth was revised higher from 4.5% to 6.3% and July’s year over year growth was 6.1%. This month over month weakness is off a strong base.

chart 2

Residential spending on new multi-family homes was down 2.8%. Spending on new single family homes was down 0.4%. Home improvement spending was up just 0.1%. Private non-residential spending was down 0.3%. Public spending on education projects and highways and streets fell along with commercial spending on power projects. Manufacturing spending was up.

Construction spending’s sequential decline was caused by weakness in new housing construction, shortages in skilled construction workers, and heightened prices for construction raw materials. The increase in steel prices is caused by the tariffs.

Q2 earnings update

This earnings season has been strong. The latest results as of August 2 show EPS growth was been 25.53%. The average EPS estimate beat has been 6.06%. The consumer discretionary sector is leading the pack with an average beat of 8.64% with 58% of its firms reporting results so far. 94% of the 50 healthcare firms which have reported, have beat estimates. In total 81% of S&P 500 firms have beaten estimates.

Sales growth has been 11.08% with 381 firms reporting earnings. The average beat rate is 1.92% with 76% of firms beating estimates. The financials had the highest average sales beat rate at 3.8% with 93% of them reporting earnings. 88% of healthcare firms have exceeded estimates.

With 381 firms reporting results, the EPS growth rate is 51 basis points higher than last quarter and the sales growth rate is 2% higher. The only way you can spin these great results into a negative narrative is shown in the table below. The Q3 EPS estimates are down 85 basis points since July 1. The good news is Q4 estimates are up 7 basis points and Q1 estimates are up 21 basis points in that period.

chart 3

Subscribe to TheoTrade here...

View a brief video interview with Don Kaufman on volatility for traders and investors here

Recorded at TradersExpo New York Feb. 25, 2018
Duration: 2:34.

Related Articles on MARKETS